Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> rather than intrusive in-page ads, Brave ads show up as a notification in your operating system

I'm sorry, how is that not orders of magnitudes MORE intrusive?



One of my biggest gripes with modern software is using notifications for things that shouldn't actually be notifications. IMO, marketing/advertising NEVER should be a notification. Notifications are for things where you find value in being interrupted such as receiving a message from someone you know or letting you know you have an appointment upcoming so you don't miss it. They're not there to tell you about some arbitrarily made up sale or discount. Any app that abuses notifications is instantly uninstalled from my phone which is why I have so few apps.


Brave ads don't track you around the web and sell your data to other advertisers. Brave ads don't slow down the pages your browsing, or get in the way of the content you're trying to view. And, Brave ads are optional; you only view them if you want to support the pages/news sites/YouTube channels you're viewing.


Total propaganda war here. No they are not opt in for a site, you opt in and then they always show, you only share tokens if you choose to do so.

And who tells me brave is not tracking me? If anything they have even better data than eg Google.


>No they are not opt in for a site

The parent never claimed that. And since the ads aren't tied to specific sites I'm not even sure how that would make sense.

>And who tells me brave is not tracking me? If anything they have even better data than eg Google.

Feel free to examine their privacy policy and their source code. If you find they are doing something contrary to what they claim please be kind enough to share your findings. Just as you would for Firefox, Linux, or any other open-source software.

Until then, it's fine to be sceptical but can you please dial back the inflammatory "propaganda war" rhetoric. It's unnecessary.


Nope; Brave uses zero knowledge proofs to show you ads based on your browsing history without needing identifying information: https://news.bitcoin.com/zero-knowledge-proofs-tech-behind-b...

>A Zero-knowledge proof or Zero-knowledge protocol (ZKP) is a cryptographic method wherein the identity of the proof bearer is separated from the authenticity or truth of the proof – the cryptographic proof requires no extra trust or knowledge to be verified by its recipient. The system used by Brave is based on Anonize.


It is a lot more intrusive in my experience. I'd get notifications about random blockchain conferences all the time before I figured I had to disable brave rewards to get rid of them.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: