Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I really wish the idea that apps need to open websites in-app would go away. Like it looks neat when you're demoing it for your coworkers but it just increases the number of taps since to do anything useful I need to open in in Chrome/Safari anyway.

If the in-app browser was just a window into actual Chrome/Safai (i.e. it's a real tab when you open Chrome/Safari and has your logins bookmarks, etc.) and you could "pull" the window into the foreground as a slick transition to the browser app then it would be fine, but as it's implemented it's mostly just annoying for everything but oauth flows.



Hmm, that’s strange because I mostly find the ability to open websites in-app very useful: The context of how I was directed to the website exists in the app. I feel that if the site I’d moved to Safari, I eventually forget how I got to this site.

I think the problem isn’t in the WebView model - It’s probably that you have to use the browser to do something useful that WebViews can’t.


That’s exactly how chrome custom tabs on Android work. Moving the app custom tab to the browser does not even reload the page.


Chrome custom tabs have access to your passwords and autocomplete history, for what it's worth


This is essentially an Oauth flow...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: