Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Google +1 Button For Websites Comes Tomorrow (searchengineland.com)
41 points by christianwilde on May 31, 2011 | hide | past | favorite | 16 comments


Assuming this post is correct, Google is launching a "like button" that doesn't do anything useful. The value of a Facebook "like" is that it gets me into a user's social feed. All this Google button appears to do is give me a rating system for my content. Am I missing something?


If your friends +1'd something that is shown in a search result, aren't you more likely to click on it rather than the other results?


Who are my Google friends? I'm not being snarky, I'm not sure who they would be. People I've emailed via gmail?


Take a look here http://www.google.com/s2/search/social

If you add your social profiles to your google profile, Google will add all your contacts in those social networks to your "social circle". Also your gmail contacts, or people you follow on google reader and so on.

More info here http://code.google.com/apis/socialgraph/

Basically, google is collecting all the public social data to build the most complete social network they can.


Gmail has started suggesting friends to 'consider including' on emails. Personally, this has resulted in both me and my ex getting some very uncomfortable suggestions recently for whom to consider including in correspondence. It hasn't suggested we email each other, which would be forgivable, but a third party whom I had never directly emailed. And it highlighted for me what I consider to be a major problem with Google's social initiatives, which is that they've collected and employed this 'social' data in a completely antisocial way--behind your back, when you're using unrelated services. And it might be clever, but it can get very creepy.


And this is one of the pitfalls of testing things internally at a company like Google.

There are a lot of important use cases in social networks around "me and my recent ex", but within a corporation you'll be unlikely to run into them. (Similar issues caused a lot of complaints for Google buzz.)


They're chasing taillights. You know what Google and Facebook have in common? They both worry about Facebook.


I don't think the suggested recipients feature pulls from other users' contacts. You, your ex, and the third party have probably been recipients of the same message in the past.


Yeah, I don't know how you define friends. They already show "Foo shared this on twitter" for some results (with a link to the twitter profile), which I've found quite useful.


From the article: "Right now, the only way those within your social network on Google will see what you’ve +1′d is if you have effectively created a fresh network just for this, deliberately chosen to expose your +1 activity, and if you’re friends know exactly where to look to see this."


Seems to me ripe for abuse and also ripe for stories of collateral damage.


Why would it be any more abused then the Facebook Like button?


Because, potentially, it can be used by Google to increase site rankings.


Google already uses signals from the Facebook Like button and Twitter tweets to increase site rankings, give them a little more credit!


I'll buy 10,000 GMail accounts and write a Ruby library to do this if likes can influence non-friends' SERPs. Being #1 = $$$


Cool! Something else to block in my hosts file besides those insipid Facebook comment URLs.

It's nice that google and facebook are putting all of your inane comments at easily-blockable URLs.

Thanks Google and Facebook!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: