Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Fake it all you want until your fakery harms innocent parties.


What's an example of a fakery that doesn't harm innocent parties? If you pretend a product (or a feature) that doesn't exist exists, then at the very least a competitor is unfairly harmed.


Innocent is perhaps the operative word. If investors expect and/or used to certain amount of fakery they are not "innocent" [1] or if the competitors are doing the same thing they are not necessarily "innocent" either.

[1] In this context to take meaning as knowledge, not meaning "not guilty" here.


If a site like Reddit gets started by creating nonexistent or sock-puppet users, for instance, that's hardly on the same level as falsifying medical tests "just until we get the bugs sorted out."


The conviction here was defrauding investors, not defrauding medical tests.

If Reddit included those sock-puppet users in their metrics to investors, then that would be roughly equivalent fraud.


In the legal sense, competition doesn’t qualify as an innocent party.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: