Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Nobody forced Putin to invade.

However, the US government certainly signed off on pre-war decisions to extend Nato into Ukraine, paying to modernize the Ukrainian military, and Joint military exercises in the Black Sea.

Not being part of these decisions, You and I can only speculate on how they fit into overall US strategy and how the risk-rewards were weighed.

My concern as a US citizen is that the current war in Ukraine seems to be a great benefit for the USA in almost all regards. I am skeptical but would hope this was not a factor in the decisions leading up to the war.



> However, the US government certainly signed off on pre-war decisions to extend Nato into Ukraine, paying to modernize the Ukrainian military, and Joint military exercises in the Black Sea.

All of this occurred after 2014. What happened in 2014? Everything that is happening in that region is due to Putin and Russia’s own actions.

This is not a great benefit to the US whatsoever. It takes attention away from Asia. The US has been reaching in to its stockpiles and coffers to make sure Russia doesn’t get what it wants.


>What happened in 2014

A revolution in Ukraine where a pro-Russia government was removed and a pro-NATO one came to power. This is extremely relevant.

>Everything that is happening in that region is due to Putin and Russia’s own actions.

To be clear, I am not denying Russia's agency and aggression. Similarly, I don't think it is realistic to say that the US has made zero decisions, has zero influence, has zero power, and zero interests in the region.

>This is not a great benefit to the US whatsoever.

This war has imposed real costs to Russia and has a real chance of destabilizing Russia for the foreseeable future, perhaps breaking it. It is extremally cheap compared to other wars and being fought without loss of American lives. The conflict is taking nothing away from US efforts in Asia.

Honest question: If you were a US military strategist, would you sacrifice Ukraine to destroy Russia? Would you sacrifice Ukraine to simply damage their military?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: