Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

If you require taxpayers to consent to every single line item, voting is going to become rather cumbersome.


[flagged]


I will bring this up every time someone mentions this, but your money is not being taken without consent. You are signing tax forms without knowing what they mean in law and voluntarily (incorrectly) giving it to them. Income taxes are excise taxes.


You can migrate and renounce citizenship. Staying and benefiting from the spending is tacit consent no?


There is no such thing as tacit consent.


The fact that there’s a term for it which we all know suggests otherwise. It’s literally in textbooks, too, so you’d have a better argument if you explained your conceptual disagreement rather than trying to pretend the concept doesn’t exist.


taken without consent; every constituent who voted for every representative who ratified the 16th amendment is now dead

Isn't it nice when you get nerd sniped by complete nonsense? I wanted to see what amendments would get invalidated using the quoted line of reasoning, aside from the whole Bill of Rights. Using the date of ratification from Wikipedia and subtracting the voting age at the time gives you the absolute lower limit of the age of any voting constituent:

    Am  Ratified    VA  Latest BD   Age
    -----------------------------------
     1  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
     2  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
     3  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
     4  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
     5  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
     6  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
     7  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
     8  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
     9  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
    10  12/15/1791  21  12/15/1770  254
    11  02/07/1795  21  02/07/1774  251
    12  06/15/1804  21  06/15/1783  241
    13  12/06/1865  21  12/06/1844  180
    14  07/09/1868  21  07/09/1847  177
    15  02/03/1870  21  02/03/1849  176
    16  02/03/1913  21  02/03/1892  133
    17  04/08/1913  21  04/08/1892  132
    18  01/16/1919  21  01/16/1898  127
    19  08/18/1920  21  08/18/1899  125
    20  01/23/1933  21  01/23/1912  113
    21  12/05/1933  21  12/05/1912  112
    22  02/27/1951  21  02/27/1930   95
    23  03/29/1961  21  03/29/1940   84
    24  01/23/1964  21  01/23/1943   82
    25  02/10/1967  21  02/10/1946   79
    26  07/01/1971  21  07/01/1950   74
    27  05/07/1992  18  05/07/1974   50
Using the SSA cutoff date of 115 years, we see that the 20th and the 21st are a bit iffy, which isn't so bad because the 21st is the repeal of the 18th, and the 20th is a bit technical, but: women's suffrage is kaput! Slavery is OK again! Senators are to be appointed! Etc. At least term limits still apply, whew.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: