Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Yes, 5k will make a difference. How about the top 1000?


Average household debt is 154k. Average household credit card debt is 11k.

How 5k will make a difference?


Because a household typically has more than one person in it, which immediately means no credit card debt.


How about the top 10,000? How about any wealth you personally have? At what point does it stop being OK for you to take people's wealth? When someone becomes a billionaire?

This reminds me of when Bernie Sanders was asked why it's OK for him to be a millionaire and he said something akin to "If you write a popular book like I did, you can be a millionaire too." Well maybe if you reinvent electric cars and space travel or build a company that ships you almost anything you can think of within 2 days then you can be a billionaire.


We can decide the point collectively. After you have enough to live a comfortable, fulfilling life, you don't need more money.


I agree we can/should decide collectively. But when the vast majority of Americans have a place to live, air conditioning and heat, a refrigerator, enough to eat, etc. it's hard not to say that they're comfortable. As for fulfilling, that's describing a utopia.

I recognize there are still people who are food insecure, and I think it's an abomination how people are suffering (many poor rural black people in the south don't even have access to basic plumbing and end up with diseases like hookworm), but making wealthy people into a boogeyman just seems like an emotional argument so much of the time.


A person does not need to own a house to live a comfortable fulfilling life. 400 sq. ft studio apartment is enough for a single person.

If there is no public transportation available, an old Toyota Yaris is also enough to have a comfortable commute.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: